How does he find about the discovery process? Can anyone guess what happened next? Petersen that having seen the film did not qualify one to be a federal judge during a disastrous hearing when Petersen could not answer basic legal questions.
What is this meeting called? Why is the victim not a party in the case? I think there are many Americans who form their impressions of our justice system through TV and movies, moreso than from first-hand experience such as jury duty. James Pollock Does Alabama require lawyers admitted pro hac vice to retain local counsel?
According to the script, Vinny was dyslexic and that was why he failed the bar exam six times and why his wife did the reading for him. Let me give you a concrete example.
But there are also a lot of scenes that would have even a nit-picking lawyer nodding his head in approval. Although Vinny is certainly no role model when it comes to knowledge of the law, legal analysis and ethical behavior, law students could learn from him as to how to use legal thinking in the complexity of actual law practice.
They were simply in the wrong place at the wrong time in the wrong car. Still, I do find My Cousin Vinny to be a funny yet unrealistic courtroom drama.
James Pollock March 15, at 3: Paul Newman was more compelling in The Verdict. And while it ultimately gets a lot of its procedure right, the criminal justice system that it depicts too often bears little resemblance to reality.
James Pollock March 14, at 7: With the setting updated to contemporary times, the series depicts the further cases of Vinny Gambini with Mona Lisa operating as his investigator. If you do not particularly care for courtroom procedure and reality, you could potentially find this movie to be entertaining.
The book featured real moments from actual courtrooms. Better lawyers succeed in disguising their arguments as mere statements of fact, unlike Vinny, who is over-the-top argumentative in his opening. What are the characteristics of Cross-Examination? Though the film is set in Alabama, the production actually shot in three separate small towns in Georgia.
Now, how would you feel if suddenly you learned that guy is your lawyer? Only questions posted as Public are visible on our website.
What you have to do is make assumptions that he is actually a smart guy, and the law is just complicated and boring. Marisa Tomei dropped out. Posted on March 14, by Max Kennerly, Esq.
The smartass in me was quite pleased to know the Rules of Federal Procedure better than the two pre-eminent trial lawyers.My Cousin Vinny is a American comedy film directed by Jonathan Lynn, from a screenplay written by Dale Launer.
The film stars Joe Pesci, Ralph Macchio, Marisa Tomei, Mitchell Whitfield, Lane Smith, Bruce McGill, and Fred Gwynne (in his final film appearance). This month marks the twentieth anniversary of the premiere of the film My Cousin Vinny and, to commemorate the occasion, our friends over at Abnormal Use have invited legal bloggers to post their thoughts on the film.
Abnormal Use itself will feature a series of posts over the week, including interviews with Vinny’s producer and screenwriter. You. My Cousin Vinny is a farce but, as New York Times film critic Vincent Canby noted, “the film has a secure and sophisticated sense of what makes farce so delicious.” That “secure and sophisticated sense” allows it to take the reality of trials — the reality of limited budgets.
As with most courtroom dramas, My Cousin Vinny relies on the pretense that the audience lacks any knowledge of courtroom procedures.
Unfortunately, I do have some ideas about how the legal system operates. Corrected mistakes for My Cousin Vinny (). Corrected entry: It is a potentially serious ethical violation for Vinny to represent both Billy and Stan at the same time. An attorney owes a duty of complete loyalty to each client s/he represents, and Billy and Stan's interests will not necessarily be the same throughout the trial (one may want to plead guilty, the other may not, for example).
An Overview of My Cousin Vinny essaysThe movie, Though the elements of criminal justice and court room policies and procedures deviated somewhat from reality, the movie incited constructive debate for years to come.